• 360-306-1410
  • smokywoodsretreats@gmail.com
  • Cosby, Tennessee
  • Home
  • All Properties
    • Smoky Woods Lodge
    • Rivers Edge Cabin
    • Swimming Hole Cabin
    • Mountain Rest Cabin
    • Maddron Bald Mountain Home
    • King Pool Cabin
    • Trailhead Lodging
      • Trailhead Lodge #1
      • Trailhead Lodge #2
      • Trailhead Lodge #3
      • Trailhead Lodge #4
      • Trailhead Lodge #5
      • Trailhead Lodge #6
      • Trailhead Lodge #7
      • Trailhead Lodge #8
      • Trailhead Lodge #9
      • Trailhead Lodge #10
      • Trailhead Lodge #11
      • Trailhead Lodge #12
      • Trailhead Lodge #13
      • Trailhead Lodge #14
    • Up the Creek Cabin A
    • Down the Creek Cabin B
    • Cozy Creek Cabin
    • Ash Creek Cabin
  • Services
    • Full Management
    • Listing Audit
    • Self Management
    • Owner Resources
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Home
  • All Properties
    • Smoky Woods Lodge
    • Rivers Edge Cabin
    • Swimming Hole Cabin
    • Mountain Rest Cabin
    • Maddron Bald Mountain Home
    • King Pool Cabin
    • Trailhead Lodging
      • Trailhead Lodge #1
      • Trailhead Lodge #2
      • Trailhead Lodge #3
      • Trailhead Lodge #4
      • Trailhead Lodge #5
      • Trailhead Lodge #6
      • Trailhead Lodge #7
      • Trailhead Lodge #8
      • Trailhead Lodge #9
      • Trailhead Lodge #10
      • Trailhead Lodge #11
      • Trailhead Lodge #12
      • Trailhead Lodge #13
      • Trailhead Lodge #14
    • Up the Creek Cabin A
    • Down the Creek Cabin B
    • Cozy Creek Cabin
    • Ash Creek Cabin
  • Services
    • Full Management
    • Listing Audit
    • Self Management
    • Owner Resources
  • Blog
  • Contact
Best Pizza Places in Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge
  • June 23, 2025

Best Pizza Places in Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge

Looking for the top pizza places in Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge? From wood-fired classics to family-owned hidden gems, this guide highlights the most-loved pizzerias—complete with Yelp ratings, costs, and unique highlights. Order up!

Best pizza places in Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge

1. Big Daddy’s Pizzeria (Pigeon Forge & Gatlinburg)

⭐ Yelp rating: #2 in PF, #1 in Gatlinburg area
💰 Price: $12–18/slice, specialty pies $18–24
Why it stands out: A 550°F brick oven delivers crispy, Neapolitan-style pies using fresh dough and no freezers .
📋 Review snippet: “Food felt like a total hit… best restaurant we went to!”

2. Jersey Hustle Pizzeria (Gatlinburg & Pigeon Forge)

⭐ Yelp rating: 4.1 stars—“fantastic! crispy but not too thin”
💰 Price: $14–20/large pie
Why it stands out: Thin-crust fans love the crisp, high-quality toppings. Ranked 4.8 on TripAdvisor
📋 Review snippet: “Great food and service.”

3. West By God Coal Fired Pizza (Pigeon Forge)

⭐ Yelp rating: Frequently top-rated for coal-fired pies facebook.com+15yelp.com+15yelp.com+15
💰 Price: $15–22 per coal-fired specialty pizza
Why it stands out: Known for smoky flavor dishes like bacon jam and fried pepperoni rolls — locals rave about these unique flavors from Facebook reviews.

4. Mellow Mushroom (Pigeon Forge)

⭐ Yelp rating: 4.0+ (popular favorite) yelp.com
💰 Price: $12–18 for medium pizzas
Why it stands out: A classic chain with creative pie options and a cozy, artsy atmosphere. Loved for its quality and consistent flavor.

5. Luigi’s / Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria (Gatlinburg)

⭐ Yelp rating: Top 5 among Gatlinburg pizzerias
💰 Price: $14–20 per specialty pizza
Why it stands out: Authentic Italian pies and garlic knots—beloved by locals and visitors alike. A true Italian experience right on the Parkway.

6. J. Del’s Pizza (Pigeon Forge)

⭐ Yelp rating: Consistently ranked top 10 in PF
💰 Price: $10–18 per pizza
Why it stands out: Classic American-style pizza with generous toppings; part of the local pizza scene and included by our cabin guests.

🔍 Quick Comparison Table

Pizza PlaceYelp ⭐ RatingPrice RangeStandout Feature
Big Daddy’s Pizzeria#1–2 in Gatlinburg/PF$12–24Wood-fired oven; no freezers, authentic crust
Jersey Hustle Pizzeria4.1 (Yelp), 4.8 (TripAdvisor)$14–20Thin-crust perfection, high-end toppings
West By God Coal Fired PizzaTop coal-fired spot$15–22Smoky flavors & local favorites
Mellow Mushroom4.0+$12–18Creative pies, artsy vibe
Luigi’s / Best Italian CafeTop 5 in Gatlinburg$14–20Italian authenticity and cozy atmosphere
J. Del’s PizzaTop 10 in PF$10–18Classic, hearty American pizzas

Why Locals and Visitors Vote These Pizza Places #1

  • Big Daddy’s wood-fired pies offer that smoky oven flavor, consistently ranking top in both Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge
  • Jersey Hustle’s thin crust and crispiness shine, with glowing local and TripAdvisor feedback .
  • West By God offers a unique twist with coal-fired pies and creative sides—earning love in Facebook comments.

Best Pizza Places to Eat in Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge

If you’re searching for the best pizza places to eat in Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge, this curated guide hits all the must-visit spots—from Neapolitan to coal-fired—and includes local favorites and rave reviews. Each place offers something special, whether it’s wood-fired crispiness, thin-crust mastery, or authentic Italian charm.

🏡 Stay with Us After Pizza Night!

After indulging in Pigeon Forge or Gatlinburg’s best pizza, unwind in our cozy cabins. Budget-friendly yet charming, they offer all the comforts you need after a delicious night out. Book now and experience the flavors—and stay—of the Smoky Mountains!

Save this post for later — pin it to your Smoky Mountain board.

Save to Pinterest

Our Properties

Our Cabins

A look at the cabins we manage across Gatlinburg, Pigeon Forge, Sevierville, and Cosby.

Maddron Bald Mountain Home

Sleeps 6  •  Hot Tub  •  Trailhead Access  •  Flowing Stream

Book here →

Mountain Rest Cabin

Sleeps 10  •  Fire Pit  •  Hot Tub  •  Game Room  •  Smart TVs

Book here →

Smoky Woods Lodge

Sleeps 12  •  Fire Pit  •  Hot Tub  •  Game Room

Book here →

Swimming Hole Cabin

Sleeps 12  •  Private Swimming Hole  •  Hot Tub  •  Creekside Fire Pit

Book here →

King Pool Cabin

Sleeps 10  •  Heated Indoor Pool  •  Mountain Views  •  5 King Suites

Book here →

Trailhead Venues

14 Unique Units  •  Hot Tubs  •  Full Kitchens  •  Fire Pits

Book here →

Up the Creek Cabin A

Sleeps 4  •  Private Hot Tub  •  Balcony  •  Waterfront Fire Pit

Book here →

Down the Creek Cabin B

Sleeps 2  •  Waterfront Fire Pit  •  Balcony  •  Pet Friendly

Book here →

Rivers Edge

Sleeps 6  •  Private Creek Access  •  Fire Pit  •  Hot Tub

Book here →

Cozy Creek Cabin

Sleeps 6  •  Private Creek Access  •  Fire Pit  •  Hot Tub  •  Fireplace

Book here →

Ash Creek Cabin

Sleeps 8  •  Hot Tub  •  Creekside Fire Pit  •  Pet Friendly

Book here →

Brand New Pool Cabin

Sleeps 12  •  Private Pool  •  Mountain View  •  Game Room & Hot Tub  •  Fire Pit & Outdoor Dining

Book here →
On Key

Related Posts

Smoky Woods Retreats cabin cabin cosby gatlinburg

What to Know Before You Buy a Smoky Mountain Cabin as a Short-Term Rental

Before you fall for a view and a listing sheet that says “STR-ready,” here’s what we’ve watched trip up new cabin owners in Gatlinburg, Pigeon Forge, Sevierville and Cosby — and what to check before you close.

Rustic cabin kitchen with stone backsplash and mountain view

10 Kitchen Must-Haves Every Smoky Mountain Airbnb Needs

Guests cook more in a mountain cabin than almost anywhere else they stay. Here are the 10 kitchen items we make sure are in every cabin we manage, and why each one keeps reviews five-star.

Smoky Woods Retreats cabin trailhead lodge 1

How the Airbnb and VRBO Algorithms Actually Rank Smoky Mountain Listings

Airbnb and Vrbo rank your Smoky Mountain cabin on far more than photos and price — response rate, cancellations, review recency, and conversion all quietly decide your search position. Here’s what we’ve seen actually move listings up or down.

Layered blue-green ridges of the Great Smoky Mountains under a pastel evening sky near Cosby, Tennessee

Late-October Color by Car: Foothills Parkway, Newfound Gap Road & the Cosby-Side Drives We Actually Take

By the last week of October, the high ridges have mostly gone brown and the show has moved down into the coves and foothills, right

Smoky Woods Retreats cabin mountain rest

What to Do When Something Breaks and You Don’t Live Near Your Cabin

When your cabin’s HVAC or hot tub fails and you’re hours away, the clock on refunds, reviews, and Superhost status starts immediately — here’s what separates owners who handle it from owners who don’t.

Smoky Woods Retreats logo

Check out our Social Networks to see what other guests experiences were like!

Facebook-f Instagram
Quick Links
  • Home
  • All Properties
    • Smoky Woods Lodge
    • Rivers Edge Cabin
    • Swimming Hole Cabin
    • Mountain Rest Cabin
    • Maddron Bald Mountain Home
    • King Pool Cabin
    • Trailhead Lodging
      • Trailhead Lodge #1
      • Trailhead Lodge #2
      • Trailhead Lodge #3
      • Trailhead Lodge #4
      • Trailhead Lodge #5
      • Trailhead Lodge #6
      • Trailhead Lodge #7
      • Trailhead Lodge #8
      • Trailhead Lodge #9
      • Trailhead Lodge #10
      • Trailhead Lodge #11
      • Trailhead Lodge #12
      • Trailhead Lodge #13
      • Trailhead Lodge #14
    • Up the Creek Cabin A
    • Down the Creek Cabin B
    • Cozy Creek Cabin
    • Ash Creek Cabin
  • Services
    • Full Management
    • Listing Audit
    • Self Management
    • Owner Resources
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Home
  • All Properties
    • Smoky Woods Lodge
    • Rivers Edge Cabin
    • Swimming Hole Cabin
    • Mountain Rest Cabin
    • Maddron Bald Mountain Home
    • King Pool Cabin
    • Trailhead Lodging
      • Trailhead Lodge #1
      • Trailhead Lodge #2
      • Trailhead Lodge #3
      • Trailhead Lodge #4
      • Trailhead Lodge #5
      • Trailhead Lodge #6
      • Trailhead Lodge #7
      • Trailhead Lodge #8
      • Trailhead Lodge #9
      • Trailhead Lodge #10
      • Trailhead Lodge #11
      • Trailhead Lodge #12
      • Trailhead Lodge #13
      • Trailhead Lodge #14
    • Up the Creek Cabin A
    • Down the Creek Cabin B
    • Cozy Creek Cabin
    • Ash Creek Cabin
  • Services
    • Full Management
    • Listing Audit
    • Self Management
    • Owner Resources
  • Blog
  • Contact
Get In Touch
  • Email: Smokywoodsretreats@gmail.com
  • Phone: 360-306-1410
  • 3891 Cosby Hwy, Cosby, TN 37722

© All Rights Reserved.

Information on this site is provided for general guidance only and is sourced from what we believe to be reliable sources at the time of publishing. Regulations, pricing, and availability can change — always verify anything that affects a legal or financial decision directly with the relevant authority or provider.

Sample Airbnb listing audit PDF cover with an overall scoreSample audit — 8 pages, in your inbox within 24 hours

Airbnb Listing Audit

Is Your Listing Leaving Bookings on the Table?

Get a professional review of your Airbnb title, photos, captions, description and amenities — with clear fixes to help you stand out and book more stays.

$9.99 PDF in your inbox within 24 hours
Get my audit → See what’s inside a full sample audit →